Heard a thing where the UK is gonna start handing out fines for playing music on the train without headphones and like,

There's always a contingent of people who'll say about anything, ah this is tyranny, this is a slippery slope or whatever, but who'll also agree that this thing is a pain in the arse and everybody wants it to stop and they don't have any better ideas on how to stop it and like, whatever, I was more agog at the AMOUNT of the fine and what it says about how nobody knows what's a reasonable amount of money anymore

'cause I heard at first that it was gonna be a fucking GRAND.

And like... no working person is gonna enforce that. That's completely out the window. If I'm a train conductor and some lad's blasting music on his phone and I've got the option to make him pay a grand, I'm not gonna do it, because the point of a fine is to fuck your day up enough that you stop doing the thing, and a grand won't just fuck up your day, it can fuck up your whole life. Like fucking hell you might as well throw them in prison.

Then I read that it was gonna be more like a hundred quid, the make-them-pay-a-grand idea was just some dipshit politician mouthing off, and I'm like... yeah that's still too much.

Like I recall when the smoking ban came in and there were signs everywhere saying, £200 fine for lighting up in the pub. Round where I was, that was two weeks' rent. Having to pay a two hundred quid fine would mean you'd miss the minimum on your credit card and you'd be down another twenty quid fee from that and it might take you years to dig out. Nobody had that kind of money.

And stuff like that, it just points to how once you've got past a certain amount of money, you forget what it's like to live... the way that most people live, y'know?

I mean fucking hell every time I fill up the car and I HOLD THE HANDLE CLOSED UNTIL IT STOPS I remember that I spent most of my life very definitely not doing that and I'm enormously lucky to be in the situation where I grumble about prices and worry about the future rather than panicking about Right Now.

The people talking about a hundred quid fine probably don't think a hundred quid is a lot of money. If I'm a train conductor I'm not gonna pass out a hundred quid fine to some antisocial headphone-dodging kid 'cause I know that it's probably going to cause him an amount of pain and disruption that enormously outweighs the annoyance he's caused. It's not justice.

Like yeah a grand fine will get the job done, but a tenner fine would also get the job done, or at least 90% of the job done, and not ruin lives in the process.

Like fucking hell lads look what charging 5p for a carrier bag did

And yeah there's a good argument that fines in themselves are shite and you'll not find me arguing against that but again, this is what we've got, it's this or putting people in prison or community service or whatever, and while a day picking up litter is the same for a rich person as for a poor person it really doesn't fit the crime in this situation

Fines being inherently unjust can be mitigated, not all the way but to some degree, by reducing the amount ('cause it makes no difference to those rich enough either way but it lessens the harm done to normal people) but I think the fairest solution is to put all the headphone dodgers in the spiders box.

See the spiders don't know if you're rich or poor, and even if they did they wouldn't care. Blasting shit music from your phone? Half an hour in the spiders box, rich or poor, young or old. Blasting GOOD music from your phone? That's 40 minutes 'cause phones make good music sound shit and that's worse

Fedi how much money do you have in your bank account right now, boost for science

Follow

@ifixcoinops thinking about how i've never had more than 4k gbp to my name and that was purely because they took so long to assess me for disability benefits and had to backdate payments.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Computer Fairies

Computer Fairies is a Mastodon instance that aims to be as queer, friendly and furry as possible. We welcome all kinds of computer fairies!