that youtube thing
Yeah, I'm done supporting it for a few reasons.
Let's start with the time limit on it. That's not how strikes and boycotts work people. You don't just do it for a few days. You keep going until you get what you want. This will accomplish *nothing* because the higher ups at youtube *know* they can just wait it out. A few days from now, all but a few of the people supporting this will go right back to using youtube. They can wait.
that youtube thing
Two, the lack of organization. Far smarter people than I have mused on this far better than I, but basically, it's got next to no organization, which really isn't gonna lead to anything. I mean hell, it was barely communicated. Most of the info on it is apparently on youtube of all places, and a lot of people seem to only be finding out about it *as it happens*. I, for one, only learned of it yesterday morning. How are you gonna present any demands with this kinda organizing?
that youtube thing
And guess what! They probably won't come for your favorite youtuber anyways! If they use this clause, it'll be on people like me, who have no subscribers, 4 views, two videos, with the last one posted a year and a half ago! You know, easy targets! Not people watched by a lot of people who'd easily be able to stir up outrage over their channel being shut down! You're yelling at youtube for all the wrong fucking reasons!
that youtube thing
Is youtube shit? FUCK YES. Are there lots of things that need to change? FUCK YES. Is this one of those things that needs to change? Probably. Should it be the top priority and the sole reason we try to do anything against youtube. NO.
that youtube thing
Fucking, get your shit together, organize something, have some actual fucking demands that youtube can't easily evade, then fucking follow through until your demands are met. There are useful things to come out of this, but all of it is realizing you can actually do all the stuff I just mentioned. You're figuring out you can organize. Now, fucking do it *effectively*.
that youtube thing
And, finally, the demands themselves. It seems all this fuss is over that clause on youtube being able to shut down "commercially unviable" channels. Spoiler alert: They already could. Another spoiler alert: Any concession will be nothing more than a "There, there, sweetie. We promise we won't hurt you." They may change the ToS, sure, but it'll basically be rewording it in a less controversial manner. They *will* retain that ability.