Follow

Doctor Who 

It frustrates me that some of the Doctors are "blocked off" from having new companions in fanfic.

As an example: the 1st doctor always gains a new companion before the previous one leaves the TARDIS, which means that one of the companions in the TV show must [i]always[/i] be there. I can't write a story which is "the First Doctor travels with my fan characters Viola and Vermi and no-one else".

The 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 5th Doctors are all "blocked off", but...

[continued]

Doctor Who 

...each of these Doctors has a different level of blocked-offness.

The 1st Doctor is completely blocked off, unless you set the story on Gallifrey in the time before he stole a TARDIS and ran away with his granddaughter.

The 2nd Doctor is completely blocked off, and in a worse scenario: the 2nd Doctor's travels cannot possibly exceed a few years, because of Jamie, who was with the 2nd Doctor the whole way through... if it wasn't for the workaround (which I'll come back to.)

[cont.]

Doctor Who 

The 3rd Doctor is sort of blocked off. He spends most of his time exiled on Earth, which means that most stories are set in the few years that he was working with the Brigadier at UNIT.
But, there is a time jump between Season 10 and Season 11, where:
• he has gained back the ability to use the TARDIS again
• he hasn't got any companions.

You could theoretically put new companions in there, but then you have to explain why he bothers to come back to work with UNIT.

Doctor Who 

The 5th Doctor has a similar situation to the 1st Doctor - there's always an overlapping set of companions, and the Doctor never travels alone.

The 4th, 6th, 7th, 8th, 10th, 11th, and 12th Doctors are all explicitly shown to be traveling on their own.

The 13th Doctor has only had 1 set of companions so far.

The 9th Doctor is a bit tricky - he can never be traveling alone *after* Rose joins the TARDIS in S01E01. But he can be alone before (and during*) that episode.

Doctor Who 

*There are multiple points in S01E01 where the Doctor takes off in the TARDIS. Which means that from the Doctor's perspective, the story could actually be spread over several months, with him going on a bunch of adventures before returning to London to deal with the Autons.

Doctor Who 

With the 2nd Doctor: in his last TV story, he is forced to regenerate by the time lords. But since they hadn't cast Pertwee yet, they don't actually show the regeneration.

This has lead to many stories that star the 2nd Doctor alone, but set while he's trying to run away from the Time Lords so that he doesn't have to regenerate.

Fans call this period "Season 6b", but it isn't actually a fan theory – it's been confirmed as true by the events of The Five Doctors and The Two Doctors.

Doctor Who 

@lizardsquid The first Doctor had John & Gillian in the comics. Prose (novellas, short stories in Annuals, etc.) featured at least seven different non-TV 1st Doctor TARDIS teams, one including a bulldog. Big Finish also has a non-TV companion. The Doctor's timeline is something of a multiverse onto itself.

Of course, you can also unblock by separating from companions (Twice Upon a Time) or extracting from timeline (Three Doctors, Five Doctors). How many adventures will Clara yet have?

Doctor Who 

@beadsland I had forgotten about John and Gillian!

The main thing for me is that I just wish the TV series left more gaps where you can insert stories without having to be like "and then the Doctor was kidnapped and had some adventures off screen in the middle of this episode but you didn't notice and they didn't mention it at all".

(also: didn't the Big Finish companion travel with the 1st Doctor AND Steven?)

Doctor Who 

@lizardsquid Yeah, well, the model of storytelling was more serial than episodic then, and fanfiction really only took off in the era of episodic stories.

But what John and Gillian, and the Annuals, and, heck, the Cushing films, tell us is that canonicity also wasn't really a major concern of the time either. Characters were archetypes more than histories. You did with them what you would.

When in the Doctor's history did John and Gillian happen? Does it matter? They had adventures.

Doctor Who 

@lizardsquid Add to that the very timey-wimeyness of the Whoniverse—you've got to ask the question of whether, by the time later incarnations and their adversaries got done mucking with timelines, the events chronicled in the early series still happened, or at least happened just that way?

That was a timeline, but the Doctor doesn't live in that timeline anymore. For all we know, that timeline doesn't exist anymore. Today's Doctor's history might look little like what we saw on TV.

Doctor Who 

@lizardsquid As an example: Did the Doctor's Wife TARDIS ever travel with the 4th, 5th or 6th Doctor?

In a New Adventures novel, the 7th Doctor lost and subsequently destroyed his TARDIS. At the end of the story he was traveling in the TARDIS of a deceased alternate-timeline 3rd Doctor.

It was the same TARDIS that stole the Doctor from Gallifrey, and yet it wasn't the TARDIS shattered by meteors on Frontios or that traveled into eSpace.

It is THE TARDIS, and yet its history differs.

Doctor Who 

@lizardsquid Yet "off screen" stories in the middle of an episode that you didn't notice and they didn't mention at all aren't unheard of. Consider "Romans Cutaway", an entire story that falls between the first and second scenes of The Romans. This is a common trope in The Companion Chronicles.

And yes, Oliver Harper traveled with Steven and the Doctor. Yet there have been stories where a companion was dropped off or left in the TARDIS, so an Oliver-only adventure is not unthinkable.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Computer Fairies

Computer Fairies is a Mastodon instance that aims to be as queer, friendly and furry as possible. We welcome all kinds of computer fairies!