page design, opinions wanted!
I'm making a guide for doctor who, and I was wondering how I should format the page - at the moment, I've got a high details mode and a low details mode - any opinions/critique on the design would be much appreciated, though!
communication is hard
The biggest problem I've found with this project is communicating what it actually means/what it's for.
People were surprised that I said you shouldn't watch "The Daleks", because it's historically important to the series. But I'm not making this for people who want to watch every episode, or for fans. If you're one of those people, you're going to ignore my recommendations and watch everything anyway.
(cont)
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid It's good, conceptually. You may want to lighten or desaturate the blues. I recommend looking at it in grayscale to make sure it's accessible to colorblindness.
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid (You may also want to alternate shades by lightness value, so lighter and darker shades alternate. That'll also make it understandable on older hardware with less color depth or B&W e-ink, as well as being purely about physical accessibility.)
page design, opinions wanted!
@Zero_Democracy I'm not sure how to do that, because each colour corresponds with a recommendation, and you might have 2 of the same recommendations in a row
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid Ah, okay. In that case, maybe just tack some sort of alphanumerical citation on if it's not overcomplicating things.
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid It's good otherwise, though. Not a lot of fiddly bits or things fighting for visual priority. Looks like it'll scale well between resolutions.
page design, opinions wanted!
@Zero_Democracy what do you mean by an alphanumerical citation?
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid If it's just about categories, maybe something like "REC." "NOT REC." etc along the right edge of the box, or a numerical rating that corresponds to the colors in whatever order descends or ascends. Otherwise it's probably overcomplicating it.
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid While I wouldn't call it pretty, it definitely communicates very effectively. Even if you're just glancing at it quickly.
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid plz use less saturated colors lol <3
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid The colors are perhaps a little confusing, but otherwise the layout seems to be fine by me! You may consider more of a 2-3 color spectrum for consistency and denoting importance or interest?
page design, opinions wanted!
@vudw a 2-3 color spectrum? what do you mean?
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid Green-to-red along that color spectrum, or blue or another color for special notes of interest. Of varying shades. Like the ones to skip in red, ones to watch in greens, and in-betweens in lighter shades. Those maybes could maybe get a blue. (just as a vague maybe-confusing example!)
page design, opinions wanted!
@vudw it already is along a colour spectrum - from red to blue, with partial as yellow to distinguish it
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid Maybe I'm just bad with colors then, sorry. xD
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid I assume this is basic HTML & CSS?
Instead of styling the td background with your meaningful colors, consider styling one or two of the td's borders to be a thick solid line with the color instead, and leave the td background inherited from the tr background.
page design, opinions wanted!
@arielmt it's not currently HTML at all, but perhaps that's a good idea! Can't exactly do that in this program, though
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid maybe join the Season column with watch and details so there wont be a border on the whitespace
page design, opinions wanted!
@fokkfeis Sorry, I don't understand what you mean?
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid like the season row that a different color has little dots between the columns, might look better without them so the color is constant through the row
page design, opinions wanted!
@fokkfeis oh right, make it just one big row with no gaps
I will do that, although I can't actually do it in the program I'm using, I'll have to do it after I convert it to html
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid alright my dude :)
btw whats the page purpose? like a tv show/movie reviewer on per episode/series basis ?
page design, opinions wanted!
@fokkfeis it's a recommendation guide on which classic Doctor Who episodes to watch and which ones to skip
@lizardsquid maybe unbold the titles that are missing? 🤔
@00dani that works - I'll also put "missing episodes" in the story details thing (it's only visible in the first image in the first toot)
page design, final?
@lizardsquid that makes sense to me!
although - is there a meaning for the bold titles vs the italic titles?
page design, final?
@verity yes - the ones in italics are ones with missing episodes
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid use pale, no dark colors, silly =P
page design, opinions wanted!
@lizardsquid I didn't hate them! I was just down into fidgety details because that's how I look at things when they seem to work in a basic sense.
page design, opinions wanted!
removed all the colours because everyone hated them