aha! looks like they WERE in fact 3D rendered! even to the point of using a human figure as an origin point for the camera to make it look like you were actually looking at a desk top
source: https://blog.cocoia.com/2008/the-origin-of-the-inimitable-icons/
@mavica_again They knew whats up, that looks like a standing desk!
@thedaemon is that the name of the program?
@thedaemon here's the original page where that was scraped from, btw :) https://macintoshgarden.org/apps/cinema4d-xl-7
@thedaemon it's hard to tell at that resolution
i wish i could find any other source about this, but it was this hard enough to find out definitively that at least the OS X icons were actually 3D rendered and not vector gradients like everybody tries to imitate them with
@mavica_again @thedaemon This is news to me, I can't wait till tonight when I can pore over all this 🤩
@mavica_again I remember a very long time ago there was a couple pages about the design of aqua in an issue of MacWorld (I think it was MacWorld, may have been a different publication). Will have to see if I can dig it out.
this is actually a huge breakthrough for me. everyone i ever asked told me there was no way they would 3d render these, that they were all just vector drawings. i feel like i just found out the punchline to a joke everybody kept from me all these years